Private credit has become one of the defining investment stories of the past two decades.1
The appeal is easy to understand. In an environment where investors continue to seek income, downside protection, and diversification, private lending strategies can offer attractive cash yields and priority positioning in the capital structure. But as the investable universe has expanded, so too has the range of risks embedded within it.
Increasingly, the question is not whether investors should allocate to private credit, but where within private credit they should allocate.
Recent market events have provided a timely reminder that not all forms of lending are created equal. The collapse of Silicon Valley Bank in 2023, redemption pressures in certain retail-focused credit vehicles, and the significant decline in valuations across many office markets during and after the pandemic all underscore the importance of understanding what ultimately supports a loan when market conditions deteriorate.
At its core, the distinction comes down to collateral.
Loans backed by tangible, income-producing real assets offer a fundamentally different risk profile than loans primarily supported by a borrower's future operating performance. While both can generate attractive yields, the quality, transparency, and durability of the underlying collateral can have a significant impact on outcomes during periods of stress.
Commercial real estate debt provides lenders with a direct claim on physical assets and the cash flows those assets generate. By contrast, corporate direct lending frequently relies on enterprise values, intellectual property, goodwill, and other assets whose value can become more difficult to assess when economic conditions weaken.
A Federal Reserve report analyzing 10 years of data (2013-2023) suggests this distinction matters. Commercial real estate debt has demonstrated lower loss rates, stronger recovery values in distressed situations, and attractive long-term risk-adjusted returns relative to many other segments of the private credit universe. Even through one of the most challenging periods for portions of the property market, commercial real estate debt has continued to exhibit resilience as an income-generating investment strategy.
Three characteristics help explain these outcomes:
Tangible Collateral and Transparent Cash Flows
The foundation of commercial real estate debt is relatively straightforward. Loans are secured by physical assets that generate observable and recurring cash flows through lease agreements and tenant occupancy. This transparency allows lenders to evaluate collateral quality, monitor performance, and assess risk with greater confidence.
In contrast, a significant portion of direct lending activity is concentrated in sectors where collateral tends to be less tangible. Software and services companies, for example, represent more than half of direct lending borrowers, according to Federal Reserve research. These businesses often depend on intellectual property, enterprise value, or future growth expectations rather than hard assets that can be readily valued or liquidated during periods of stress.
Stronger Outcomes When Markets Become Challenging
The value of collateral becomes most apparent when borrowers encounter difficulties.
Over the past ten years, commercial real estate loans have experienced substantially lower net charge-off rates than corporate lending. A key reason is that lenders have a claim on a tangible asset that can continue generating income, be repositioned, or ultimately sold.
Recovery values have also generally been stronger, helping reduce loss-given-default and overall expected losses. While defaults can occur in any lending strategy, the presence of hard assets often provides an additional layer of protection that may not exist when lending against a business whose value depends heavily on future earnings expectations.
Attractive Risk-Adjusted Performance
For investors, the ultimate question is whether stronger collateral translates into better outcomes.
Historical performance suggests it has.2 The result has been favorable risk-adjusted performance, as measured by Sharpe ratios, across the period analyzed.
The asset class has also provided meaningful diversification benefits. Compared with many other private and public market strategies, commercial real estate debt has exhibited relatively low correlations to both public equities and corporate bonds, creating another potential advantage within diversified portfolios.
The Bottom Line
Private credit's rapid rise has created significant opportunities for investors, but it has also increased the importance of understanding what sits behind a loan.
Yield alone rarely tells the full story. The quality of collateral, the transparency of cash flows, and the likely recovery value in a downside scenario are often the factors that matter most when markets become stressed.
Commercial real estate debt is not immune to economic cycles, nor is every property sector equally attractive. However, the evidence suggests that the combination of tangible collateral, income-producing assets, and historically stronger recovery outcomes has created a compelling balance between return generation and capital preservation.
As investors continue to increase allocations to private credit, the distinction between lending against a business and lending against a real asset may prove more important than ever. When market conditions become more challenging, what stands behind a loan can make all the difference.
Learn more about private real estate debt.
1 Source: Burgiss Holdings Private Credit Indices. Private Credit capitalization represented by Active Capitalization as of Q2 2026.
2Source: MSCI Private Capital Indices via Burgiss and Bloomberg. "Real Estate Debt" is represented by the MSCI US Real Estate Debt Closed-End Fund Index.